April L. Moon
Service Area
Assistant
Administrator
Assistant Medical
Group Administrator
(also Urology) 2011
Ophthalmology/Optometry
Dr. Peter Custis
Chief Physician
2011
Dr. Padmini Kaushal
2011
SITE MAP
HOME
Thank Heaven for
Insurance Companies blog
Cardiology score card
Retaliation by Kaiser
Missing Medical Records
Warnings deleted from abnormal
test results
Conflicts of interest
Failure to diagnose
Employees, goals
Cases and news
missing x-rays
Peer review
Paul Bernstein and writers
Remediating failure to diagnose
Mary Ann Barnes
People
Kaiser executives
George Halvorson, Kaiser CEO
Profits grow as Kaiser cuts care
Blog: Kaiser Permanente
Dr. Eugene Rhee, chief
of urology
Lynette Seid, CFO San Diego
X-rays (VUCG)
James G. Malone
Psychiatry
Dave Horton
Executives
Urology score card
Kaiser Permanente links
Rankings Kaiser departments
Cancer score card
Diagnostic Imaging
Diagnosis
Medical Records
US Health Insurance companies
ERISA
consent form
Healthcare reform
Fellowship
NCQA
ADA
Arbitration
KP On Call
Other
Lawyers and doctors
Yvonne Hanzen
Nathaniel L. Oubré, Jr.
Doctors
Dr. Huathin Khaw
Dr. Jacob Birnbaum
Dr. Catherine Cheng
Dr. Jae Kyo Lee
Marina Baroff
Bertha Aviles
Garfield Specialty Center
Dr. Hamid Safari
Code of silence
Kaiser Papers.org

LIST OF WEB SITES THAT
SPECIFICALLY STUDY KAISER
PERMANENTE AND PROVIDE
ADVOCACY AND OFFER
SUGGESTIONS FOR THE
PATIENT
Member Services
Conahan v. Sebelius and Kaiser
Foundation Health Plan, Inc.
Gee v. SCPMG
Standard of care
Gynecology rankings
Medical School rankings
Board Certification
Problems at Garfield Center in
Kearny Mesa
Bad faith denial of coverage
Cases and news
Kagnoff, Marcia
Growth
Prime Healthcare v. Kaiser
Patient advocates
Gilbert Kenneth Moran
Doctors who cause death
Doctors who go along
with Kaiser tactics
San Diego
Education Report
Doctors in charge of
cover-ups
Robert Pearl
Filing a complaint
Prime Healthcare heart
failure rates--is Prime worse
than Kaiser Permanente?
Quality
Filing a complaint
Gynecology score care
Cancer
Scripps

UCSF
Perceptions of patients
Patient abandonment
Medical Board
Radiology
April L. Moon and Dr. Andrew
Golden thumb their noses at
Dr. Marianne Rochester at
Scripps
CalPERS appeal
Compliance Department
Concealing Medical Records
DOMHC (Dept of Managed Health
Care)
Politicians
Emergency room
Medicare
Added Choice
Dr. Paul Bernstein
Ophthalmology

Orthopedics
Kaiser Fired Optometrist Whistle-Blower, She Says
By BARBARA WALLACE
Tuesday, March 11, 2014
Courthouse News              
 
  RIVERSIDE, Calif. (CN) - Kaiser fired an optometrist because she and others opposed
management's illegal sales-incentive program, she claims in a complaint filed in
Riverside County Superior Court.
  Lisa Levingston, O.D. sued Kaiser Foundation Health Plan, Inc., Kaiser Foundation
Hospitals and Southern Permanente Medical Group for violations of California Health
and Safety Code, violations of California Business and Professions Code, retaliation in
violation of the Labor Code, wrongful termination in violation of public policy and
intentional infliction of emotional distress.
  Levingston was not the only one who objected to Kaiser's sales promotions that tied
optometrists' bonuses to sales of specific manufacturers' glasses and frames, nor the
only one who was punished, she says in her lawsuit. "For a number of years, Kaiser
Riverside optometrists refused to participate in these sales promotions and refused the
financial incentives," her complaint states.
  But in 2011, Kaiser Riverside's (non-party) Managing Optometrist "began to pressure
these optometrists to participate in the sales promotions that would financially incentivize
the optometrists to sell and/or prescribe certain optical products. However, plaintiff,
along with all of the Kaiser optometrists based in the Riverside medical service area,
continued to oppose these practices, which plaintiff reasonably and correctly believed
were in violation of California law and the Code of Professional Ethics," according to the
complaint.
  "In response to plaintiff's complaints of Kaiser's unlawful conduct, Kaiser orchestrated
a series of escalating disciplinary actions against plaintiff and those optometrists who
supported her and shared plaintiff's complaints," Levingston says.
  Before Levingston opposed the incentives, she had received excellent performance
reviews and patient satisfaction ratings, according to the complaint. But as she began
trying to address the problem, Kaiser started giving her written correction notices based
on bogus accusations, she says.
  Levingston says the Managing Optometrist wrote false information in a patient's chart,
claiming the patient had complained about Levingston's work and had asked to speak to
a manager. Although Levingston provided management with an affidavit from the patient,
declaring that those statements were untrue and asking for them be removed from her
chart, other false charges against Levingston continued to escalate, she says.
  Other complaining optometrists also faced retaliation, including bogus disciplinary
actions, loss of privileges, and negative performance reviews backdated to make it
appear that their purported shortcomings were longstanding, when in fact they had
materialized in response to those doctors' complaints about the incentive program,
according to the lawsuit.
  However, Levingston says she was specially targeted because, as co-chair of Kaiser
Riverside's Local Professional Practices Committee (LPPC) it was her responsibility to be
the spokesperson for optometrists in the department. "The purpose of the LPPC is to
provide a forum for joint decision making regarding the practice of optometry as it relates
to the Riverside service area," she says.
  Levingston says that when the Managing Optometrist put her on administrative leave
and ultimately fired her, the reason given was that Levingston had failed to answer her
office door quickly enough when the Managing Optometrist knocked, and had not
immediately stopped what she was doing to put on a badge with a new Kaiser sticker on
it, according to the complaint.
  Levingston reports that she had worked for Kaiser for 21 years.
  Levingston seeks economic and non-economic damages, special and punitive
damages, prejudgment interest, attorneys' fees, injunctive relief and costs of suit.
  She is represented by Charles T. Mathews of The Mathews Law Group in Arcadia.

See
complaint HERE.